Plastic Vs. Stainless Steel Water Bottles: Which to Use

Written by Dr. Bill Booker

On May 2, 2017

Over the past few years, there has been a push to get consumers away from drinking out of plastic water bottles. You may even have heard the debate over plastic vs. stainless steel water bottles.

Is it an environmental issue to reduce the waste associated with disposable plastic bottles? Is it an effort by makers of alternative water bottles to get people to buy their product, or is it a concern about the effect of chemicals in plastic on water?

What’s the truth? The answer is: plastic definitely isn’t a good choice. I recommend using stainless steel water bottles instead.

Why Stainless Steel Water Bottles?

Most of the research has centered around what happens when a plastic water bottle is heated up. Informal studies began by looking at water bottles that had been sitting in parked cars and had warmed up to a dangerous temperature (greater than 125 degrees Fahrenheit). The purpose was to understand what happens to a plastic bottle when it is warmed, and how warm plastic affects water quality.

The findings show that when a plastic water bottle is heated, several chemicals from the plastic leech into the water, the most significant being Bisphenol A or BPA, an industrial chemical used to make hard, clear plastic used in many consumer products.

BPA is a hormone-mimicking chemical that has the properties of synthetic estrogen. Predictably, a synthetic estrogen like BPA affects hormone levels and is linked to several significant health concerns, including hormone-sensitive cancers like breast cancer and prostate cancer. Research has also linked BPA to various other heart, brain, and hormone-related issues.

Turns out, BPA remains in the water even after the bottles are refrigerated. But parked cars aren’t the first place where BPA leeches into the water. When plastic bottles are shipped on packing trucks, the trucks routinely heat the bottles beyond safe levels, and the BPA leeches into the water before it even arrives at the point of sale.

An interesting side note: The FDA has been aware for some time that BPA can leech into food. The FDA has identified substances that can migrate from packaging into food, and those substances have to receive pre-market approval from the FDA as an “indirect food additive.”

The original approval for BPA under this regulation dates back to the 1960s. Studies on BPA as a toxic chemical didn’t start until the early 2000s. There is some debate as to the amount of BPA that is dangerous, but it is widely accepted that beverages readily contain a higher dosage than most food products.

Nonetheless, momentum is growing to reduce the likelihood of ingesting the hazardous BPA. Countries like Canada, as well as several U.S. states, are looking to make BPA illegal for use in packaging of consumable products.

The best way to eliminate BPA from your diet is to simply avoid food or drinks stored or shipped in plastic containers.  Another suggestion is to avoid heating food in plastic containers, especially in a microwave.

Another trend that is growing among some food and beverage companies is to label products as “BPA Free,” but really the most practical alternative is to avoid plastic altogether, particularly water bottles, and to carry and use stainless steel or glass bottles that definitely don’t contain BPA.

Obviously there are some tradeoffs to carrying around a container that needs to be refilled rather than just buying a fresh, cheap plastic bottle of water when you’re thirsty. There’s also a tradeoff between using alternative products like glass or stainless, steel, but in my opinion, generally speaking, stainless steel is more practical because the bottles aren’t at risk for breaking like glass water bottles are. Also, with the right shape and labeling, they are easy to carry and look cool.

2 Comments

  1. susan mcelhinney

    Good for you!
    Also, we need to be aware of how much of that plastic ends up in our environment— particularly the ocean— where it is ingested by sea turtles, birds, fish, whales and seals— killing them. Many species eat jellyfish as a primary diet and the plastic mimics them. Bad for us and bad for them.

    Susan McElhinney
    Senior Photo Editor
    Ranger Rick Magazine
    National Wildlife Federation
    11100 Wildlife Center Drive
    Reston, VA 20190
    mcelhinney@nwf.org
    703-438-6525
    http://www.nwf.org

    Reply
  2. Cindy

    I appreciate the information – Thank you!

    Reply

Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

What To Read Next

Violent Attack Leaves Athlete and Friend of Capitol Rehab Hospitalized

Violent Attack Leaves Athlete and Friend of Capitol Rehab Hospitalized

UPDATE Dec. 14, 2021: Last week we shared with you the tragic news of Friend of Capitol Rehab and former Paul VI High School basketball star 23-year-old Corey Manigault, who was brutally attacked in Cyprus while out celebrating with his European League teammates after...

Photos: Capitol Rehab’s 25th Anniversary Party!

Photos: Capitol Rehab’s 25th Anniversary Party!

What a great time we had at Capitol Rehab's 25th anniversary party at The Lot in Arlington. We had 100 guests show up even after the early evening storm threatened to dampen the entire evening. We ate, drank, laughed, and enjoyed being outdoors. Several guests knew...

Capitol Rehab of Arlington Celebrates 25 Years of Service

Capitol Rehab of Arlington Celebrates 25 Years of Service

Capitol Rehab of Arlington, the chiropractic and physical therapy practice that started in the basement of Gold's Gym in Clarendon in 1996, is celebrating 25 years of service in 2021 with a celebration that spotlights its community relations. Now located in the Quincy...